State of AI Visibility:
New York Roofers
An in-depth algorithmic audit of local search performance and AI recommendation visibility.
Over half of New York roofers (75%) score under 51. AI skips them.
We checked 142 roofers in New York. Reviews matter more than skill. Most lack the data AI needs. The gap keeps growing.
The 2026 problem:
- 49% of searches start with AI assistants
- 80% of New York roofers have no AI-ready data
- 75% stay hidden from AI search
- AI search grows 15-20% each year
Bottom line: Good work (4.4★ avg) but no AI-readable data. AI can't recommend what it can't read.
Key Findings
107 of 142 roofers (75%) score under 51. Only 1 (0.7%) hit 76+. Almost everyone is invisible.
Only 20% have structured data AI can read, despite 100% having websites.
Top 10% average 172 reviews. Bottom 50% average 16. That's a 10.8x gap. 53% have under 20 reviews—too few for AI to trust.
4.0★ with 200 reviews beats 5.0★ with 20. AI trusts volume over perfection.
100% have websites. Only 0.7% score well. A website alone won't help.
Median: 23 reviews. AI typically needs 50+ for reliable visibility.
The Gap
Top 10% vs Bottom 50%
The Breakdown
Market Overview
142 roofers in New York. A few are visible. Most are not.
How they score:
- Excellent (76-100): 1 roofers (0.7%)
- Good (51-75): 34 roofers (23.9%)
- Fair (0-50): 107 roofers (75.4%)
Most roofers are either strong or weak. Little middle ground.
Average score: 40.7/100 Median score: 38.5/100
Most roofers cluster around the median. Small fixes can jump you from bottom 50% to top 25%.
Score Spread:
This table contains detailed data best viewed on a larger screen. Please switch to desktop to view.
| Range | Count | Percent |
|---|---|---|
| 0-25 | 15 roofers | 11% |
| 26-50 | 92 roofers | 65% |
| 51-75 | 34 roofers | 24% |
| 76-100 | 1 roofers | 1% |
Real example:
Someone asks ChatGPT: "Find me a good roofer in New York."
AI names 3-4 businesses. All from the 1 top scorers. The other 141 roofers don't exist to it.
Score Distribution
By Market Percentile
Reviews: The #1 Factor
Review count beats ratings, years in business, or fancy websites for AI visibility.
Review Counts
New York roofer reviews:
- 0 reviews: 20 roofers (14%)
- 1-19 reviews: 55 roofers (39%)
- 20-49 reviews: 27 roofers (19%)
- 50-99 reviews: 16 roofers (11%)
- 100+ reviews: 24 roofers (17%)
Average: 64 Median: 23
Half have 23 or fewer reviews. AI needs 50+ to trust you.
Top vs. Bottom
This table contains detailed data best viewed on a larger screen. Please switch to desktop to view.
| Tier | Count | Avg Reviews | Median | AI Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top 10% | 15 roofers | 172 reviews | 113 reviews | 70.2/100 |
| Bottom 50% | 71 roofers | 16 reviews | 4 reviews | 28.1/100 |
| Gap | — | 10.8x | 28x | +42 pts |
Top performers get steady reviews. AI rewards recent activity.
Ratings: Not Enough
Average rating: 4.4★
Most New York roofers have good ratings. But ratings alone don't create visibility.
AI prefers many reviews over a few perfect ones. Volume first, then quality.
The Catch
The Data Problem
New York roofers lack the data AI uses to pick who to recommend.
When AI assistants recommend contractors, they evaluate verification signals across three categories: Identity, Legitimacy, and Readability. Most New York roofers pass Identity checks (physical address, phone number, Google listing) but fail Legitimacy and Readability—the factors that separate recommended contractors from invisible ones.
What AI Looks For
1. Identity (25 pts)
- Google Maps listing
- Address confirmed
- Phone verified
- Website works
2. Trust (35 pts)
- 4.5+ rating
- 50+ reviews
- Own domain website
- Same info everywhere
3. Data Format (40 pts)
- Structured data (JSON-LD)
- LocalBusiness schema
- Services listed clearly
- Standard contact format
New York Gap
- 100% have websites
- 20% have structured data
- 80% are missing AI-readable data
Even roofers with great reviews stay hidden if AI can't read their data.
Fix this now: VerifiedNode implements the complete verification infrastructure AI systems require, making your business machine-readable and recommendation-ready. Get verified →
AI Trust Index Analysis
What Winners Do
The 1 roofers scoring 76+ share these patterns. The 75% below don't.
Full Digital Setup
All top performers have:
- Working websites (vs. 100% overall)
- Complete Google profiles
- Same name/address/phone everywhere
- AI-readable business data
Top in New York
This table contains detailed data best viewed on a larger screen. Please switch to desktop to view.
| Type | Score | Rating | Reviews | Website | Schema |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roofing contractor | 82/100 | 5.0★ | 327 | Yes | Yes |
| Roofing contractor | 74/100 | 4.7★ | 483 | Yes | Yes |
| Roofing contractor | 71/100 | 4.6★ | 124 | Yes | Yes |
| Roofing contractor | 71/100 | 4.6★ | 280 | Yes | Yes |
Review Systems
Top performers ask for reviews:
- Email/text after each job
- Direct Google review links
- 3-5 new reviews per month minimum
Bottom performers hope for reviews. Top performers collect them.
The Winner's Playbook
Unlock the Full Report
Subscribe to view the detailed analysis, performance charts, and receive quarterly market updates.
Action Plan
Scoring 0-40 (50%)
This week:
-
Finish your Google Business Profile
- List 8-12 services you offer
- Add your service area
- Upload 10+ project photos
- Verify hours and payment methods
-
Start collecting reviews
- Send review requests 48hrs after jobs
- Use direct Google review links
- Target: 3-5 new reviews/month
In 90 days:
- Get to 25+ reviews
- Reply to every review
- Get VerifiedNode verification
Scoring 40-60 (Middle 50%)
You're close. Focus and you'll break through in 6 months.
Focus on:
- 4-6 reviews/month
- Get verified (structured data)
- Add service keywords
Scoring 60+ (Top 24.599999999999998%)
You're visible. Now compete with 90+ scorers.
Next level:
- Full verification
- Detailed review responses (50+ words)
- Track AI appearances monthly
Get verified: VerifiedNode implements complete verification infrastructure for AI recommendation systems. Get verified now →
Claim Your Territory
Ensure ownership of your listings on Google, Apple Maps, and Bing. This is the foundation of your visibility.
Speak AI Language
Use Schema.org markup to help AI models understand your specific services.
Active Reputation
Visual Proof
Top 10
These businesses have optimized their digital footprint for AI search, maintaining consistent schema data, high-quality reviews, and verified identity signals.
Stop Being Invisible
Join New York contractors already visible to AI.
60-day guarantee. No risk.
Stay Informed
Receive quarterly market updates and new AI visibility strategies.